Thomas P. Brennan Jr., Chief Merchandising Officer at Casey's General Stores Inc. (NASDAQ: CASY), sold 3,000 shares on June 29, 2026, totaling $2,359,590. Shares sold at prices ranging from $779.88 to $799.83. Following the sale, Brennan directly holds 11,171 shares and indirectly holds 402 shares through a 401k plan.
Casey's stock currently trades at $674.84, down 27% from the high end of Brennan's sale price range. The stock has declined 22% over the past six months. The company has a market capitalization of $24.95 billion and trades at a P/E ratio of 32.41. InvestingPro analysis indicates the stock is overvalued relative to its Fair Value.
Brennan holds restricted stock units scheduled to vest across multiple dates through June 2029 under the 2018 and 2025 Stock Incentive Plans.
Several analysts recently adjusted outlooks on Casey's. RBC Capital upgraded the company to Outperform but lowered its price target to $825 from $910. BMO Capital maintained an Outperform rating while reducing its price target to $810 from $950. KeyBanc lowered its price target to $780 from $970 while keeping an Overweight rating. William Blair added Casey's to its Analyst Conviction List with an Outperform rating.
Investors watching CASY should monitor whether the stock can stabilize above $674.84 or continue lower toward the reduced analyst price targets of $780-$825.